On 9 November 2016, the unthinkable happened: Donald Trump was
elected 45th President of the United States of America. Since then the
US has not only lived up to the worst anti-American clichés touted by
the extremes of Left and Right – it has surpassed them. A year of
‘America First’ has put a serious strain on ties between the US and its
European allies. But is the relationship really in crisis?
Let’s start with the positives. The US president may have offended
numerous heads of state and government, but he hasn’t (yet) provoked a
war. At home, Trump has only managed to push two major projects through
Congress: a long-anticipated
tax overhaul and the
appointment of the conservative Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court.
Otherwise, it seems America’s famed system of ‘checks and balances’
is still functioning pretty well – especially when compared with the
creeping authoritarianism we see in some EU member states such as
Hungary and Poland. It’s no Russia or China either.
Following Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris climate agreement, a
number of US states created a ‘Climate Alliance’ committed to reducing
greenhouse gas emissions. Several American cities are offering refuge
and support to immigrants from Latin America facing deportation. US
courts have blocked plans preventing transsexuals from joining the
military, and knocked down three attempts to ban Muslims from certain
countries from entering the US.
(The Supreme Court has since reinstated the ban.)
Trump’s efforts to do away with ex-president Barack Obama’s
healthcare reforms have failed. Plans to build a wall along the Mexican
border have also come to nothing. Encouragingly, the US Department of
Justice appointed Robert Mueller to oversee an FBI investigation into
the president’s Russian connections and those of his entourage. So
despite countless presidential tweets attacking the system, the
separation of powers is still working.
A joint European security and defence policy is long overdue, and
PESCO is just the latest in a long list of initiatives and experiments.
As we have seen, Europe is highly inefficient when it comes to defence
spending. Much work is needlessly repeated: the EU has 17 types of tank,
29 types of frigates and destroyers, and 20 types of fighter jets.
Procedures for joint missions are complex, the financing arrangements
risky.
PESCO is a first step in the right direction. It doesn’t herald the
‘mega-army’ some have predicted. Rather it puts forward an ambitious aim
of cooperating intelligently and boosting military capabilities by
avoiding unnecessary duplication and using limited resources more
effectively.
This includes the establishment of a joint European Defence Fund
(EDF) of €500 million; the European Defence Agency, founded in 2004; and
the creation of smaller EU battlegroups (military units) to respond to
and prevent crises. If successful, PESCO will represent a first step
towards greater European independence in the area of security policy.
We should also take care to ensure justified criticism of Trump
does not lead to defeatism, cynicism, self-righteousness or
anti-Americanism. European countries have no other option but to
continue working with the Trump administration as best they can, whilst
seeking to maintain contact with Congress and work with American
politicians who take an interest in Europe, as well as with NGOs and
think tanks.
We must do everything in our power to ensure that not only is there
life after Donald Trump, but that the project of the ‘West’ still
exists. It is also important that the EU, when there is disagreement,
stands in unity against Britain and America, the former leading powers
on each side of the Atlantic.
We need both: more Europe and more democracy on the one hand, and the
preservation of transatlantic foundations for the post-Trump era on the
other. Democracies must respond to the advance of authoritarian
structures and individuals by democratising their security policy,
because democracy and peace are inextricably linked.
We must observe and enforce rules and standards, and we need credible
sanctions against those who break them. We need to expand international
(criminal) jurisdiction and to strengthen international organisations
and the rights of national parliaments and civil society at home and
abroad. If Europe is to overcome the significant challenges facing our
world, it must involve the authoritarian superpowers of China and
Russia.
However, that cannot replace a newly-aligned transatlantic
partnership, where Europe and the US stand on an equal footing. Trump is
not America and he will not be in power forever. The goal must be to
ensure that the next American president does not take office with the
western world in ruins.
Read more: Will the EU-US relationship ever be the same again? | International Politics and Society - IPS