If there is one thing that the British tabloid press and populist politicians (and many others besides) get exercised with and enjoy exaggerating about even more than the EU, it's immigration. No less during a time of economic crisis when scapegoats and easy answers are on high demand.
Immigration has been a cause célèbre for the coalition since coming to power. Promises to cut numbers of immigrants, attacking foreign students, even questioning the free movement of people in the EU have been employed to appease and at the same time fuel populist sentiments. It is also used as a stick to attack the UK’s membership of the EU, which is blamed for any perceived or real increase of immigrants. Rhetoric against immigration and the EU alike has been rife recently and it has been further inflamed because Bulgarian and Romanian citizens (whose countries joined the EU in 2007) are to be given access to the British labour market at the end of the year. Senior Conservative Ministers are already creating an atmosphere of speculation around the notion that such a move will produce negative effects.
But as it’s often the case with populist causes and tabloid obsessions the facts are widely ignored. Take the charge that immigrants come here to pillage Britain’s generous welfare system, for example. Figures from an IMF Working Paper collated as recent as 2011 paint an interesting picture. When measuring the gross replacement rates (the ratio of unemployment benefits a worker receives relative to the worker’s last gross earning) in the first year of unemployment across the world, Britain fares remarkably poorly. As one works his way down this table he quickly realises that our welfare system does not look all that generous, does it?
Immigration is neither a burden on our welfare system nor a threat to
the domestic workforce, certainly not in the scale implied by certain
politicians and newspapers. On the contrary, immigrants, who often take
up job natives do not desire (the social care sector being a prime
example) make a significant contribution to the economy (by spending on
goods and services in this country and contributing to national GDP),
the taxation and welfare system, the talent pool available in the labour
market and last but not least the cultural wealth of Britain. Instead
of demonising them we should be celebrating the role they play in this
country.
Read more: Immigration is a boon for society, and the EU should be praised for encouraging it
No comments:
Post a Comment